Description
| Name | Born-Died | Description / Note |
| Victim | ||
| Halliday, Paul | 1823-1893 | x |
| Suspects | ||
| McNally, Lizzie | 1860-1918 | x |
| Family of Victim | ||
| Ellen | x | first wife |
| Halliday, James | born 1859 | 4th son |
| Halliday, John | 1851-1891 | 2nd son and also a victim |
| Halliday, Mary | born 1854 | 1st daughter |
| Halliday, Margaret E. | born 1864 | 2nd daughter |
| Halliday, Paul Jr | 1857-1919 | 3rd son |
| Halliday, Robert | born 1848 | 1st son |
| McNally, Lizzie | x | second wife |
| Law Enforcement & Lawyers | ||
| x | x | x |
| x | x | x |
| Witnesses & Other People | ||
| x | x | x |
In addition to the above, there were the following jurors:
[Gallery]
Timeline
- 1893
Testimonies
Documentation
Burial Records:
- Cemetery: City, County, State, Country
- Names (Born-Died)
Census Records:
- Census Name: City, County, State – Family
City Directories:
- City, County, State: Names
Crime Scene Location:
- Mamakating, Sullivan, New York
Newspaper Articles
- New York World (New York City, New York)
- 1893 (Oct 22): “Nellie Bly Visits Mrs. Halliday”
- 1893 (Nov 5): “A Woman Without a Heart”
- New York World, Evening Edition (New York City, New York)
- 1893 (Sep 5): “All Dread Mystery”
Vital Records:
- Birth:
- YEAR: Name
- Marriage:
- YEAR: Names
- Death:
- YEAR: Name
